"...Aristotelian arguments above made use of classes. The ... relata herein are propositions [not classes]—Stoics called these ‘sayables’—rather than classes. In Aristotelian logic, the key connectives are ‘all’, ‘some’, ‘is’, and ‘is not’. In Chrysippus’ logic, the key connectives are ‘if’, ‘or’, ‘and’, ‘not’. "
"The Enthymeme is a (rhetorical) syllogism". Aristotle, Reth. II, 22
"Rhetoric may be defined as the faculty of discovering the possible means of persuasion." Aristotle, Reth. I.2.1
Labels
Philosophy
(28)
Logic
(22)
Probability
(21)
Argumentation
(20)
Ramus
(20)
Literature
(15)
Assumptions
(14)
Handouts
(11)
Mathematics
(11)
Metaphors
(11)
Quotes
(11)
Matlab
(10)
Tropes
(10)
Method
(9)
Quintilian
(9)
Induction
(8)
Modeling
(6)
Book Reviews
(5)
Collingwood
(5)
Physics
(5)
Problem Structuring
(5)
Analogies
(4)
Historiography
(4)
System
(4)
Aphorisms
(3)
Classical
(3)
Evidence
(3)
Fallacies
(3)
People
(3)
Religion
(3)
Transitions
(3)
Decision Making
(2)
Dynamic Programming
(2)
GIS
(2)
Linear Programming
(2)
Poetry
(2)
Sayings
(2)
Toulmin
(2)
Writing
(2)
economics
(2)
Art
(1)
Bach
(1)
Policy
(1)
Regression
(1)
Risk
(1)
Chrysippus and his indemonstrables modes of reasoning
From the Jeremy Kirby's entry on Chrysippus in the IEP.
"...Aristotelian arguments above made use of classes. The ... relata herein are propositions [not classes]—Stoics called these ‘sayables’—rather than classes. In Aristotelian logic, the key connectives are ‘all’, ‘some’, ‘is’, and ‘is not’. In Chrysippus’ logic, the key connectives are ‘if’, ‘or’, ‘and’, ‘not’. "
Modus ponens: If p, q; p; ergo, q. : p→q, p, ∴q
Modus tollens: If p, q; not q; ergo, not p. : p→q, ¬q, ∴¬p
Modus ponendo tollens: Either p or q; p; ergo not q.: p∨q, p, ¬q
Modus tollendo ponens-1: Either p or q; not q; ergo p.: p∨q, ¬q, p
Modus tollendo ponens-2: Not both p and q; p; ergo, not q. ¬(p∧q), p, ¬q
"...Aristotelian arguments above made use of classes. The ... relata herein are propositions [not classes]—Stoics called these ‘sayables’—rather than classes. In Aristotelian logic, the key connectives are ‘all’, ‘some’, ‘is’, and ‘is not’. In Chrysippus’ logic, the key connectives are ‘if’, ‘or’, ‘and’, ‘not’. "
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment